13A is here to stay but it has to be fine-tuned BY P.K.Balachandran

The recent statements made by President Ranil Wickremesinghe and those attributed to the leaders of the Samagi Jana Balawegaya (SJB) and the Sri Lanka Podujana Peramuna (SLPP) make it clear that the 13th Amendment to the constitution (13A) that devolves some powers to the Provinces has the tacit support of the Sri Lankan political parties notwithstanding overt opposition to it.
In his Special Address to Parliament on August 10, the President stated the reasons for thinking that the 13A is necessary even as he said that the working of the Provincial Councils (PCs) set up under the 13A left much to be desired and suggested changes.

The SJB’s General Secretary Ranjith Madduma Bandara said: “We are in favour of devolution and the 13th Amendment. However, we do not want them to be used as smokescreens to delay elections.” The SLPP General Secretary Sagara Kariyawasam said that for the time being, no “expansion” of the 13A should be attempted because the country is faced with a grave economic crisis. He did not say that 13A should go. In fact, when he was President, SLPP patriarch Mahinda Rajapaksa had said that if he abolished the PCs, those politicians who were demanding abolition would be the first to agitate for its retention!

If 13A exists today, it is not because of India’s pressure but because the Lankan political system finds it useful. President Wickremesinghe said this about the 13A in Parliament: “The Provincial Councils have nurtured skilled political leaders and served as stepping stones to executive and parliamentary roles. Throughout history, numerous individuals who embarked on their political journey as Provincial Council members ascended to positions of power like the executive presidency, premiership, cabinet membership, and other significant roles. Many of the Ministers currently seated in this House have traversed a path from provincial council members to Chief Ministers and beyond. None of the parliamentary political parties advocates for the abolition of Provincial Councils. Representatives from all these parties have engaged with and been part of Provincial Councils.”

“The PCs have become an enduring component that cannot be excised from Sri Lanka’s governmental structure or political landscape,” the President said.

Consensus on the need for 13A was reached by the Steering Committee formed for framing a new constitution during the 2015-2019 Yahapalanaya regime. However, the President stressed the need for the 13A to be implemented “in a manner that aligns with Sri Lanka’s development and future.”
Referring to the drawbacks in the working of the PCs, the president pointed out that the LKR 550 billion spent on them every year, needed to be examined for their rationale. Further, the division of power and authority between the PCs, the central government, and the local bodies lacked clarity. “Subjects overlapped resulting in duplication of efforts and delayed actions.”

Steering Committee’s Recommendations

The interim report of the Steering Committee on a new constitution released in September 2017 recommended (1) Ensuring the participation of PCs in the formulation of national policies concerning matters within the Provincial List; (2) Avoiding transfer of constitutionally decentralized powers from the PCs to the Central Government; (3) Abjuring the practice of taking over the implementation of the National Policy on a Provincial subject.

There were proposals to grant authority to the PCs to provide education-related services at the school level, establish Provincial Boards for Vocational and Technical Training Services and Universities, provide grassroots agricultural innovation services and promote provincial tourism.

The President said that the Industries Act needed to be amended to increase the limit for industries of national importance from LKR 4 million to LKR 250 million. This could be raised to LKR 500 million.

He proposed to establish District Development Councils to chalk out a three-year plan for each provincial council in alignment with the central government’s national policies. Central government development programmes should be customized for each district and execution should be entrusted to the PCs.

There should be a legal framework to enable MPs, PC members and members of Local bodies representing each district to collaborate effectively in this endeavour. The President further said that a committee, led by the Prime Minister, will be established to re-evaluate the List of powers held by the central government, and provincial councils. The concurrent list would also be examined. The President suggested allowing Members of Parliament to contest in provincial council elections.

On the delicate subject of granting police powers to the PCs as per 13A, the President said: “It would be more practical for us to initially focus on reaching consensus concerning other powers. It’s advisable to progress step by step.Prioritizing sensitive matters could potentially hinder the attainment of any mutual agreement.”

EPDP’s Step by Step Reform

The Eelam Peoples’ Democratic Party (EPDP) led by Fisheries Minister Douglas Devananda had submitted a step-by-step approach to the reform of the 13A.

Stage I involves retaking functions taken over by the Centre through executive means in the last 36 years. This could be done through Administrative means. Stage II involves amending (a) certain Acts that were enacted prior to the passing of the 13A so that these are in line with the provisions of the 13A. (b) repealing certain provisions of the Provincial Councils Act No. 42 of 1987 and Transfer of Powers (Divisional Secretaries) Act No. 58 of 1992 to facilitate the smooth functioning of the PCs. These amendments could be done by a simple majority in parliament of those present and voting.

The EPDP cited some cases as examples. Agriculture and Agrarian Services is a Provincial subject. But it was taken over by the Central Agriculture Ministry. That was challenged in the Supreme Court. The Court ruled that “Agrarian Services” is in the Provincial List. And yet, the Central Agriculture Ministry continued to hold on to the subject by changing the name of the Department to “Department of Agrarian Development!”.

The Turnover Tax on wholesale and retail sales is the main revenue earner for the Provinces provided in the 13A. But that tax was done away with, and the Centre began collecting the Value Added Tax (VAT) and sharing a percentage with the Provinces. The PCswere thus deprived of an independent source of revenue.

As per the Constitution, the Finance Commission’s duty is to make recommendations to the President on the principles on which funds should be granted to the Provinces. But in practice, the Finance Commission gives directions as to how the fund should be spent also. This is not the intended function of the Finance Commission.

As per the Provincial Councils Act, No. 42 of 1987, the appointment, transfer, dismissal and disciplinary control of officers of the public service of the Provinces are vested in the Governor of that Province and the Governor, in turn, could delegate that power to the Provincial Public Service Commission. But in defiance of this provision, the Secretary of the Central Health Ministry directly decides all appointments.

On the controversial issue of devolving Police Powers, the EPDP says that the PCs should be permitted to enroll Provincial police personnel for deploying them on duties “without carrying weapons, such as traffic duties, controlling crowds etc.”

Stage III involves Constitutional Provisions that need to be Repealed or Amended. The Centre’s power over National Policy on all Subjects and Functions, including those in the Provincial List, should go. The Concurrent List should also go. The requirement of the Governor’s assent for the statutes passed by the Provincial Council to be done away with. And the Governor should be appointed by the President with the concurrence of the Chief Minister.

Some of EPDP’s suggestions are too radical, but its case that there is a wide measure of agreement on most of its proposals may not be off the mark.

Posted in Uncategorized

Minister Thondaman’s intervention leads to justice for evicted Ratwatte Estate family

The Chairman of the Ratwatte Estate in the Elkaduwa Plantation located in the Matale district has dismissed an Assistant Estate Manager who was caught on video violently evicting a poor estate worker family, including a 2-month-old child, with a weapon.

The viral video, which showed the Assistant Estate Manager and other estate officers illegally breaking a temporary shelter for the family, throwing out their food and speaking in a derogatory manner, led to several MPs and civil society organisations raising their alarm and demanding action.

Minister Jeevan Thondaman, who is responsible for the estate sector, visited the Ratwatte estate and the family on Sunday. At the inquiry, it came to light that the eviction of the estate worker and their family was illegal, without a court order or police intervention.

The General Manager of the Estate had also threatened to throw the worker family including his infant child on to the street. The Minister had then demanded for immediate action and accountability against the responsible persons.

The Chairman and the now-dismissed Assistant Manager had expressed their sincere regrets over the unfortunate episode to the affected family. The Estate has also vowed to construct a permanent residence for the aggrieved family on its grounds and committed to construct a further 11 permanent houses for families living and working on the estate, addressing long-standing housing issues they’ve faced.

Estate workers in Sri Lanka often live in sub-standard housing without access to basic services. Estate workers are also regularly subject to inhumane working conditions and often denied their basic rights. In the viral video, the deplorable housing conditions of estate workers in the Ratwatte Estate is clearly visible.

This year, the Cabinet agreed to commemorate 200 years since the arrival of estate workers of Indian Origin. Minister Thondaman also revealed that the Government is taking several policy initiatives to address the land and housing, education, health and economic issues faced by estate workers.

In his statement on the platform X (formerly known as Twitter), the Minister emphasised that “No individual should be robbed of their dignity or a home. The legacy of being born indentured to a company must come to an end. Everyone deserves the chance to flourish, live respectfully, and be free from humiliation.”

Mano wants estate manager sacked

Meanwhile, MP Mano Ganesan urged Plantation Minister Ramesh Pathirana to take immediate action against the estate manager, calling it an act of ‘modern slavery’.

Posting a message on X, the MP said he yelled at the Plantation Minister. “Sack the Fellow, We are at the end of our patience”.

Sri Lanka president gains more support in potential presidential poll: IHP survey

An opinion poll for July for presidential election voting intent showed that Sri Lanka President Ranil Wickremesinghe has seen a steady rise in support though he is still behind opposition figures Anura Kumara Dissanayake and Sajith Premadasa.

A Sri Lanka Opinion Tracker Survey (SLOTS) polling by the Institute for Health Policy (IHP) for July 2023 showed a rise in support for Wickremsinghe to 19 percent of likely voters, but he remains well behind leftist National People’s Power (NPP) leader AK Dissanayake and opposition leader Sajith Premadasa at 39 and 33 percent respectively.

The IHP said in a statement that estimates are associated with a margin of error of 1 to 4 percent.

The trends in July largely maintain the pattern from previous months, but the latest data more strongly supports the recent up trend in support for President Wickremesinghe. They also suggest that recent gains in his support have been at the expense of SJB leader Sajith Premadasa, the IHP said.

A separate IHP survey for July showed a general decline for two major opposition parties and modest increases for the ruling party and the president’s party, though the largest share of likely voters remained unwilling to name a party they would support.

ITAK Leader Sampanthan worried about extremism

ITAK Leader R. Sampanthan raised concerns over the escalating incidents of ethnic and religious extremism in the country, especially in the Northern and Eastern Provinces.

Sampanthan also said that a lasting solution to the burning political issues of the Tamil people is in the hands of President Ranil Wickremesinghe and he is wholeheartedly willing to end the ethnic crisis that has been going on for decades.

Sampanthan, responding to questions raised by journalists on the current political situation, said that many issues, in terms of ethnicity and religion are suddenly on the rise in the country, in particular in the Northern and Eastern provinces. The TNA is always of the stance that a lasting and sustainable peace between all communities must be ushered in.

“We, as a Party never want to witness another war in Sri Lanka. Therefore, President Wickremesinghe must come forward with a lasting solution and address the political issues of Tamil community,” Sampanthan added.

Indian Intelligence Warns of Ethnic Conflict Tensions in Sri Lanka: Tamil Newspaper Editorial

In a recent development, Indian intelligence agencies have issued a stark warning about the potential for ethnic conflict in Sri Lanka. This comes in the wake of rising tensions and concerns over cultural and ethnic clashes in the island nation.

Tamil language newspaper Tamil Mirror’s editorial notes shed light on the troubling events that have led to this dire prediction. Leading up to the final presidential election, Sri Lanka witnessed a wave of anti-Muslim sentiment, marked by false accusations against Muslim individuals and establishments.

The editorial also says;

“These baseless allegations not only sowed mistrust among the Sinhalese population but were later revealed to have been fabricated for political gain, further deepening the divide.

Another significant point of contention has been the installation of Buddha statues and temples in the traditional Tamil provinces of the Northern and Eastern regions. These actions have raised eyebrows and ignited fears of cultural and ethnic provocations, as they are seen by some as a deliberate attempt to incite tensions.

The Indian Intelligence Service’s warning echoes concerns raised about the involvement of the Archaeological Department in facilitating the establishment of temples, which has led to heightened tensions among the Tamil community.

It is essential to note that the Indian Intelligence Service’s previous warnings about the April 2019 Easter bombings in Sri Lanka were tragically accurate, underscoring the gravity of the current situation.

As these tensions continue to escalate in Sri Lanka, it is becoming increasingly vital for the nation to heed these warnings and prioritize unity. Fostering unity will be crucial not only for the stability of Sri Lanka but also for its future prosperity.“

Posted in Uncategorized

India-Sri Lanka ferry service will revive historical maritime ties: TN Minister

The ferry service between India and Sri Lanka will revive historical maritime ties between the two countries, said Tamil Nadu Minister for Public Works and Minor Ports E. V. Velu.

Speaking at the meeting of coastal states development committee held at Kevadia in Gujarat on Saturday, Velu said the Nagapattinam port in Tamil Nadu was getting ready to offer the ferry service to Sri Lanka.

“To connect India with the world, the external affairs ministry has given green signal for launching a ferry service to Sri Lanka from Tamil Nadu. The ferry service will nurture the cultural ties between the two countries. Apart from increasing the domestic and international tourism, the service will also increase the trade,” Velu said.

While Nagapattinam port is getting ready for the ferry service to Kankesanthurai, discussions to commence a ferry service between Rameswaram and Thalaimannar were also underway, he said.

“The service will revive the historical maritime ties between the two countries that existed till 1980,” he said. Velu then said that a port will be developed in Cuddalore.

Source : Times of India

Posted in Uncategorized

The Katchatheevu controversy explained By T. Ramakrishnan/The Hindu

Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M.K.Stalin, on Friday, revived the debate over Katchatheevu, an uninhabited and barren 285 acre islet about 14 nautical miles off Rameswaram, by reiterating the demand for its retrieval from Sri Lanka.According to him, that would put an end to the problems of fishermen of the State.

Addressing a fishermen’s conference in Mandapam in Ramanathapuram district, Mr.Stalin pointed out that following his letters to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, fishermen arrested by the Sri Lankan authorities, were released but the boats and fishing nets, essential for the livelihood of the fishermen, had not been returned.

This was not the first time that Mr Stalin or, for that matter, his predecessors, had raised the matter. Last month, ahead of the visit of Sri Lanka’s President, Ranil Wickremesinghe, to New Delhi, the Chief Minister urged Mr Modi to raise the issue with the visiting dignitary.

When did Katchatheevu become a part of Sri Lanka?

In June 1974, the then Prime Ministers of India and Sri Lanka, Indira Gandhi and Sirima R.D. Bandaranaike, signed an agreement to demarcate the boundary between the two countries in the historic waters from Palk Strait to Adam’s Bridge.

A joint statement issued on June 28, 1974, stated that a boundary had been defined “in conformity with the historical evidence, legal international principles and precedents.” It also pointed out that “this boundary falls one mile off the west coast of the uninhabited” Katchatheevu.

The pact brought to a close the talks held between the two sides since October 1921. Initially, the negotiations were held between the governments of the then Madras and Ceylon.

How important has been Kachatheevu to the fisherfolk?

Fisherfolk of the two countries have been traditionally using the islet for fishing. Though this feature was acknowledged in the 1974 agreement, the supplemental pact in March 1976 made it clear that fishing vessels and fishermen of the two countries “shall not engage” in fishing in the historic waters, territorial sea and exclusive zone or exclusive economic zone of either of the countries “without the express permission of Sri Lanka or India.”

St. Anthony’s Church there holds an annual festival, either in February or March, drawing devotees from both sides of the Palk Bay, a tradition which has been going on.

What triggered the negotiations between India and Sri Lanka?

Sri Lanka claimed sovereignty over Katchatheevu on the grounds that the Portuguese who had occupied the island during 1505-1658 CE had exercised jurisdiction over the islet. India’s contention was that the erstwhile Raja of Ramnad [Ramanathapuram] had possession of it as part of his Zamin. According to a news item published by The Hindu on March 6, 1968 which was based on the interview of the erstwhile Raja Ramanatha Sethupathi, Kachatheevu was under the jurisdiction of the Zamin “from time immemorial” and it was the “last post’ of the Ramnad Estate. He added that the Zamin had been collecting taxes till 1947 when it was taken over by the State government following the Zamindari Abolition Act.

However, replying to the debate on the matter in the Lok Sabha in July 1974, the then External Affairs Minister Swaran Singh asserted that the decision to recognize Sri Lanka’s sovereignty over the island had been taken after “exhaustive research of historical and other records” on the islet.

How was the 1974 agreement received?

The current demand for Katchatheevu’s retrieval traces its origin to the opposition that the pact generated in 1974.

During the debates in both Houses of Parliament in July 1974, most of the Opposition including the DMK, AIADMK, Jan Sangh, Swatantara and the Socialist Party, staged walk-outs in the two Houses.

Former Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee, who was the Jan Sangh’s leader, had contended that the decision to transfer the islet had been taken “behind the back” of the people and Parliament. He was supported by Madhu Limaye, veteran Socialist leader.

The then Chief Minister M.Karunanidhi, even in 1973 when the talk of the islet transfer had been doing rounds, had urged Indira Gandhi that the popular feeling was in favour of retaining Katchatheevu which “belonged to India and not to Tamil Nadu alone,” according to a report published by The Hindu on October 17, 1973.

Three months later, he wrote a letter reiterating the stand, a copy of which was released a day after the 1974 agreement was signed.

M. G. Ramachandran, founder of the AIADMK, which was a fledgling party then, had criticised Karunanidhi for “his failure to guide the Centre properly” on the issue and sought his resignation.

When did the issue get a fresh lease of life?

After remaining low nearly for over 15 years, the Katchatheevu issue was revived in August 1991 with the then Chief Minister Jayalalithaa demanding retrieval during her Independence Day address. She later modified her demand to one of getting back the islet through “a lease in perpetuity.”

The Tamil Nadu Assembly had witnessed a number of debates on the matter. In the last 15 years, both Jayalalithaa and Karunanidhi had approached the Supreme Court on the matter.

What has been the stand of the Union government on the issue?

In August 2013, the Union government told the Supreme Court that the question of retrieval of Kachchatheevu from Sri Lanka did not arise as no territory belonging to India was ceded to Sri Lanka. It contended that the islet was a matter of dispute between British India and Ceylon (now Sri Lanka) and there was no agreed boundary, a matter which was settled through 1974 and 1976 agreements.

In December 2022, the Union government, while referring to the two agreements, pointed out in its reply in the Rajya Sabha that Katchatheevu “lies on the Sri Lankan side of the India-Sri Lanka International Maritime Boundary Line.” It added that the matter was sub-judice in the Supreme Court.

Mainstream parties not in agreement with devolving powers

Mainstream political parties are not in agreement for an extensive devolution of powers by enforcing the 13th amendment to the constitution.

Written submissions with regard to the 13A by 20 parties received so far by the Presidential Secretariat indicate this.

At the all-party conference, president Ranil Wickremesinghe asked the participating parties to submit their views by 15 August.

SLPP general secretary Sagara Kariyawasam said his party insisted that devolving powers should not be taken up at a time when the country was in financial crisis.

He added that they would vehemently oppose any move to merge the northern and eastern provinces.

Religious leaders, national organizations and intellectual groups should be consulted before deciding if the 13A should be implemented hastily, something the previous seven presidents did not took up, he also said.

SJB general secretary Ranjith Madduma Bandara said it was pointless for the government to seek opinions of other parties, without presenting its own itself.

Before considering other parties, the government should have consensus among its partners, the SJB informed the Presidential Secretariat in writing, he added.

President meets Provincial Governors

President Ranil Wickremesinghe announced the development of a novel approach aimed at optimizing the operations of the Local Council, Provincial Council, and Central Government sectors, all geared towards curbing financial inefficiencies. The President directed officials to devise this new mechanism, placing a distinct emphasis on the efficacy of these three entities.

Furthermore, President Wickremesinghe instructed officials to collaborate with Provincial Governors and Chief Secretaries in order to draft a comprehensive report on this matter within a month. These consultations are intended to ensure a well-rounded perspective before formulating the new approach.

These assertions were made during a recent meeting at the Presidential Secretariat, where President Wickremesinghe engaged with Provincial Governors and Chief Secretaries. The purpose of this assembly, held yesterday (17) afternoon, was to deliberate on the forthcoming administrative procedures associated with the provincial council system.

Expressing his views further, the President said;

Today, I’ve gathered all of you to engage in a discussion about the governance framework associated with the empowerment of Provincial Councils. Our focus needs to be on how to progress in this direction while also considering the administrative structure of the central government.

In certain instances, identical services are delivered by the three different tiers of administration: the Local Council, the Provincial Council, and the Central Government. Take, for instance, tasks like drain maintenance, electric pole installation, and road construction. Unfortunately, this redundancy results in significant financial wastage. If this is indeed the case, it becomes imperative to establish a fresh mechanism that centres around the coordination of these three entities.

I have recommended the formulation of a novel system within a month’s time, following consultations with the Provincial Chief Secretaries. This step is crucial since the provincial councils are presently non-operational and bereft of ministers. Consequently, you, the Provincial Governors, hold complete governing authority within the current provincial council system.

The previous year posed considerable challenges for us, an experience I believe we need not relive. As we strive to tackle the economic predicaments of the nation, our efforts must also encompass the restoration of the country’s governance structure.

Of notable significance is that grassroots services are overseen by the provincial councils, while district-level services fall under the purview of the central government. It’s essential that these undertakings progress harmoniously, without competing with each other, as we endeavour to offer these services jointly.

The food security program has now been successfully rolled out across the entire nation. As a result, we are optimistic about a bountiful harvest in the upcoming season. Despite a decrease in the prevalence of malnutrition among the population compared to last year, we mustn’t become complacent.

It’s worth noting that the Aswasuma program played a pivotal role in reducing malnutrition among the citizens of our country. The advantages stemming from the Aswasuma initiative extend beyond mere prosperity.

Given that the parliamentary session will continue until the close of the next year, it’s essential to extend the opportunity for parliamentarians to engage in local government matters. Additionally, plans are underway to establish a dedicated advisory committee that will collaborate closely with the governor.

Simultaneously, we are also addressing the powers of provincial councils as outlined in the 13th Amendment of the constitution. Notably, a special emphasis has been placed on enhancing education, professional training endeavours, and the establishment of new universities in each respective province.

To bolster the growth of the tourism industry, there are intentions to establish tourism boards at the provincial level. It’s also pertinent to mention that numerous programs aimed at incentivizing investors and entrepreneurs are anticipated to be implemented at the provincial level in the future.

Mr. Saman Ekanayake, the Secretary to the President, expressed his anticipation for the backing of the Presidential secretariat in addressing the challenges confronted by Provincial Councils in their interactions with the Central Government.

During the discourse, the provincial governors in attendance conveyed to the President the urgent requirement to promptly fill teacher vacancies within their respective provincial council jurisdictions. They noted the presence of surplus teachers in certain schools, juxtaposed with teacher shortages in others. In response, they sought the implementation of a teacher exchange program to rectify this imbalance.

Highlighting the issue of incomplete two-story buildings constructed under the “the best school is the nearest school” concept, the governors emphasized instances of building deterioration and appealed for the formulation of a suitable program to address this concern.

The governors also drew attention to stalled development projects for which allocations had been designated. Regrettably, the funds for some of these projects were still pending.

In addition to these matters, the Provincial Governors made a request to the President to facilitate opportunities for advancing the tourism industry at the provincial level.

Posted in Uncategorized

Sri Lanka notes battle for supremacy between US and China

Sri Lanka says a contest for supremacy is unfolding between the United States and China across the expanses of the Pacific Ocean.

President Ranil Wickremesinghe said that a power struggle is also emerging between Western nations and Russia in the context of Ukraine.

“Undoubtedly, the Indian Ocean hosts the world’s pivotal trade routes, making Sri Lanka an integral player at this stage. As we navigate these waters, it is imperative that we chart a course devoid of entanglement in these international rivalries, maintaining an impartial stance. Our foremost concern must be the safeguarding of our security within this sphere,” the President said.

He expressed these views during an address at the Presidential Colours Awarding Ceremony at the Navy Volunteer Force Advance Naval Training Centre in Boossa.

The President said that considering the evolving global landscape Sri Lanka’s security apparatus will undergo a comprehensive review.

He said that the review is poised to adopt a forward-looking perspective, intricately tied to emerging economic trends and the pressing issue of climate change.

The President said the recalibration of focus is paramount to effectively respond to the multifaceted challenges that lie ahead.

“Upon the compilation of this review report, a blueprint for modernized security policies of the National Security Council will ensue. The task of orchestrating this critical endeavour has been entrusted to Defence 2030, which has diligently appointed an adept review team. This distinguished team, under the adept guidance of former Major General Channa Gunathilake, is dedicated to the preparation of this pivotal report. In support of these efforts, a dedicated office has been established, reaffirming our unwavering commitment to ensuring the comprehensive security of our nation,” the President said.

The President said that the challenges that lie ahead extend far beyond the confines of weaponry or monetary considerations.

“Our paramount concern remains the welfare and prosperous future of our citizens, encompassing both those in active military service and those who will transition beyond it. Your dedication has not gone unnoticed, and we are committed to integrating your insights and perspectives into this new security review,” the President said at the Navy event.

The President said that the dynamics of today’s landscape witness the encroachment of global power struggles into the Indian Ocean’s realm.